Strategy Comparison

FlexVault Strategy vs Traditional Investing

Two fundamentally different approaches to wealth building. One follows Wall Street's playbook. The other prioritizes tax-free growth and downside protection.

Quick Comparison

FeatureFlexVault StrategyTraditional Brokerage
Tax on GrowthNone (tax-free)Annual (dividends, cap gains)
Tax on AccessNone (via loans)Capital gains tax
Market RiskProtected (0% floor)Full exposure
Upside PotentialCapped (10-12% typical)Unlimited
LiquidityAfter cash value buildsImmediate
Death BenefitYes (tax-free)No
Creditor ProtectionYes (varies by state)No
FeesInsurance costs + adminManagement fees (0.03-2%)
ComplexityHigher (requires guidance)Lower (DIY possible)
Best ForTax-free income seekersGrowth-focused investors

Tax Treatment: The Core Difference

Traditional brokerage accounts are taxed three ways. FlexVault? Zero.

📉

Traditional Brokerage: Taxed Three Ways

  1. Dividends: Taxed annually (even if reinvested)
  2. Capital Gains Distributions: Taxed annually (from fund turnover)
  3. When You Sell: Taxed on all gains

Example: $100,000 over 25 Years @ 8% Return

Dividend Tax (2% yield Ă— 25% tax)-$12,500+
Cap Gains Distributions-$5,000+
Final Sale (25% on gains)-$125,000+
Total Tax Drag-$142,500+

Net after-tax value: ~$542,000 (vs. $685,000 pre-tax)

🛡️

FlexVault Strategy: Tax-Free

  1. Growth: No annual taxes (Section 7702)
  2. Access: Tax-free through policy loans
  3. Death: Tax-free to beneficiaries

Same $100,000 over 25 Years @ 6.5% Net Return

Annual Tax$0
Access Tax$0
Estate Tax$0
Total Tax$0

Tax-free value: ~$480,000 + death benefit

Risk Profile: Protection vs Exposure

After a 50% loss, you need a 100% gain just to break even. FlexVault's 0% floor eliminates this math problem.

2008

-37%

Brokerage

0%

FlexVault

Recovery needed: +59% vs 0%

2020

-34%

Brokerage

0%

FlexVault

Recovery needed: +52% vs 0%

2022

-19%

Brokerage

0%

FlexVault

Recovery needed: +23% vs 0%

$1,000,000 Portfolio After 2008 Crash

Traditional Brokerage

$630,000

Need +59% just to recover

FlexVault Strategy

$1,000,000

No recovery needed

25-Year Comparison: $50,000/Year

See how the numbers play out over a realistic wealth-building timeline.

Traditional Brokerage (8% gross, 2% tax drag)

YearContributedNet Value
Year 10$500K$743K
Year 15$750K$1.32M
Year 20$1.0M$2.22M
Year 25$1.25M$3.47M

At withdrawal (25% tax): ~$2,900,000 net

FlexVault Strategy (6.5% net return)

YearCash ValueDeath Benefit
Year 10$620K$1.2M
Year 15$1.18M$1.8M
Year 20$1.92M$2.6M
Year 25$2.85M$3.5M

At access (tax-free): ~$2,850,000 + $3.5M death benefit

At Retirement: $2,500,000 Balance

Traditional Brokerage Income

4% withdrawal

$100,000/year

After 25% tax

$75,000/year

❌ Sequence of returns risk: YES

❌ Can run out of money: YES

FlexVault Income

5% tax-free loans

$125,000/year

No taxes

$125,000/year

âś… Sequence of returns risk: MINIMAL

âś… Death benefit protects family: YES

Annual difference: $50,000 more tax-free income

Best Use Cases

Choose Traditional Brokerage When:

  • âś“Maximum flexibility and liquidity
  • âś“Low tax bracket now AND in retirement
  • âś“Want to pick individual stocks
  • âś“Very high risk tolerance
  • âś“Don't need death benefit
  • âś“Want simplicity and DIY control

Choose FlexVault When:

  • âś“High tax bracket (32%+)
  • âś“Tax-free income is a priority
  • âś“Want downside protection
  • âś“Value death benefit and living benefits
  • âś“15+ year time horizon
  • âś“Want creditor protection
  • âś“Building tax-free retirement income

Use BOTH When:

  • âś“Want tax diversification
  • âś“Significant assets to deploy
  • âś“Need liquidity NOW and tax-free income LATER
  • âś“Hedging against future tax rate uncertainty
đź’ˇ

Matt Nye's Recommendation

"I'm not anti-brokerage accounts. I use them for short-term savings and speculation. But they're not my retirement strategy. Here's why:

Taxes kill compounding. A 2% annual tax drag over 25 years costs more than most people realize. Run the actual numbers—don't just compare gross returns.

Risk is underestimated. Everyone's a long-term investor until they see -40% on their statement. The 0% floor isn't exciting, but it's powerful.

Death benefit matters. My brokerage account dies with me (after taxes). My FlexVault creates an instant, tax-free estate for my family.

For high earners building retirement income, the FlexVault Strategy typically wins. Not because of higher returns—because of tax-free access, downside protection, and death benefit multiplication.

I recommend most clients have SOME brokerage exposure for liquidity and flexibility. But the serious wealth building—the retirement income engine—that's what FlexVault is designed for."

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I transfer my brokerage account to FlexVault?

Not directly. But you can liquidate (pay capital gains) and use proceeds to fund a policy. Whether this makes sense depends on your gains, tax bracket, and time horizon.

What if I need money before FlexVault cash value builds?

This is why tax diversification matters. Keep a brokerage account for short-term needs (3-5 years), use FlexVault for long-term (15+ years).

Which has better returns historically?

Traditional brokerage has higher GROSS returns. FlexVault often has higher NET returns after taxes. The answer depends on your tax situation and time horizon.

What if I die early before FlexVault cash value builds?

This is where FlexVault shines—your beneficiaries receive the full death benefit (often 10-20x what you've paid in early years), completely tax-free.

See the Comparison for Your Situation

Your tax bracket, time horizon, and goals determine which approach wins. Let's run the numbers for your specific situation.

Schedule a Strategy Comparison →